Working Paper

How Does Party Discipline Affect Legislative Behavior? Evidence from Within-Session Variation in Lame Duck Status

Jon H. Fiva, Oda Nedregård
CESifo, Munich, 2022

CESifo Working Paper No. 9697

How important are political parties in motivating and disciplining elected officials? Using a difference-in-discontinuity design, we study how shocks to incumbents’ re-election probabilities affect legislative behavior in a setting where parties fully control candidate selection. We find that within-session variation in lame-duck status has a strong negative effect on the probability of showing up in parliament to vote. We find, however, no clear evidence that lame-duck status affects the extent to which legislators deviate from the party line. Our findings align well with the citizen-candidate framework, where candidates have fixed ideological positions that do not vary based on electoral incentives.

CESifo Category
Public Choice
Keywords: political parties, party discipline, roll-call votes, legislative speech, difference-in-discontinuity design
JEL Classification: D720